Sunday, May 19, 2013

Everything Has a Meaning, At Least According to Leibniz

I have recently began reading, "Plato and a Platypus Walk into a Bar" which teaches philosophy through jokes that state philosophical concepts quite clearly. While reading, the book introduced to me Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz, a rationalist or philosopher who influenced the minds of many people with his ideas. Many of his ideas include religion, stating that everything happens for a reason. As the book states, his theory is the complete opposite of a joke where God is speaking to a man that has recently entered Heaven saying, "It's a bit embarrassing to admit, but everything that happens happens for no real reason."
If everything did happen for a reason, and if somehow the tables were turned and what was supposed to happen didn't, wouldn't we know? Wouldn't there be a series of repercussions resulting from that event? This brought me to the new idea of our own conscience. Throughout the day, we ultimately make our own decisions. We make the decision to wake up at whatever time we please, eat whatever we want when ever we want, and carry out actions of our choice throughout the day until the next. If we make our own decisions, then how is it that there is a more powerful reason behind me buying a small soda at McDonald's rather than a large other than I'm not very thirsty? What is the other reason for a bicyclist getting hit by a taxi other than that the driver was speeding and went through a red? I'm not saying that Leibniz's theory is wrong or that anyone else that is religious and believes in a higher power is incorrect, I simply am just trying to make sense of his approach in a way that I can understand.

7 comments:

  1. Really good post Finn, you showed your opinion well through writing, and did a good job questioning philosophy to find understanding. But I do believe in fate, and the thought that everything happens for a reason. I don't necessarily think of it as each individual thing has purpose, but I do believe that all your decisions combined were planned out, and form who you are as a person, and who you're supposed to be.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Great poset Finn. It does seem like Leibniz leave many holes in his theories with questions needed to be answered. In my opinion, I think stuff just happens and it's not always dependent on a godlike being controlling us. But I can see how many can agree and disagree.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Amazing post, Finn! At first I wasn't sure how the book taught philosophy through jokes, but your example was very telling. You explain your thoughts very clearly and tackled a very intense subject matter with ease! Great post!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Great post Finn! This book sounds really interesting, and slightly confusing but you did a good job trying to explain it. It seems fun to read such a philosophical book. I do think there is such thing as fate and that at least some things happen for a reason though. Maybe if a biker got hit, that would allow other things to happen in its life that wouldn't have happened if they weren't taken to the hospital.

    ReplyDelete